The Cy Youngs, 2025

About a decade ago, there was a big debate about the AL Cy Young and whether it should go to Felix Hernandez of the Mariners or David Price of the Rays.  Hernandez led in virtually every category, but was just 13-12 for a not-very-good Mariners team.  Price, meanwhile, had 21 wins for a Tampa Bay team that made the playoffs.  I was very much in the pro-Price camp.  Hernandez ended up winning the award, a clear indication that won-loss record no longer matters as much to Cy Young voters.

The same debate happened a few years later in the National League.  This time, it was Jacob deGrom and Max Scherzer.  Scherzer was the one with the wins, and he did come away with the Cy Young during that stretch when he was the best pitcher for a few years with the Nationals.

Why am I bringing this up?  Because we've got a similar situation this year.  Paul Skenes was the runaway Rookie of the Year last season, and he's quickly established himself as one of the best pitchers in baseball.  His numbers were beyond exceptional...with the exception of his record.  Skenes only went 10-10 this season.  However, the Pirates only scored 11 total runs in his 10 losses, so there wasn't much he could do on that front.  And everyone acknowledges that.  Which is why, despite his record, Skenes is the heavy favorite.  Although, he does face some stiff competition.

If the postseason were included in Cy Young voting, it very well might've been Yoshinobu Yamamoto's award.  He was brilliant in the playoffs...a complete game victory in the NLCS, then going 3-0 in the World Series (now I kinda wish he had pitched in relief in Game 3 so that he could've had a 4-0 record).  It's not like he was a slouch in the regular season, though.  Yamamoto went 12-8, had a WHIP under 1, and was second behind Skenes in ERA.  That 12-year, $325 million investment the Dodgers made in him looks like a bargain!

Then there's Cristopher Sanchez of the Phillies.  Philadelphia's rotation is one of its biggest strengths.  Sanchez emerged as the ace of that rotation this season.  And he became even more valuable when Zack Wheeler was lost for the year in August.  They didn't miss a beat, largely because of how Sanchez stepped up.  He finished the year with a 13-5 record, ranked third in the NL in ERA (2.50), and had 212 strikeouts.  Sanchez was also a workhorse, throwing more than 200 innings.

An argument can be made that Sanchez isn't the only Phillies pitcher worthy of Cy Young consideration.  Because there's also a valid case to be made for Jesus Luzardo.  His ERA was a little high (3.92), but his 15 wins were second in the NL, and his 216 strikeouts were tied for second (with Skenes).  And he was Philadelphia's fourth starter for much of the season!

Others who probably got some down-ballot votes include the Cubs' Matthew Boyd, who was as good as anybody for a few months.  I'm actually surprised Freddy Peralta isn't a finalist.  He was the best pitcher on a Brewers team that won 96 games.  Peralta led the National League with 17 wins, held opponents to a .193 batting average and a WHIP of 1.08, and had an ERA of 2.70.  And Nick Pivetta of the Padres could get some love after finishing with a WHIP below 1 and being one of just six National League pitchers with a sub-3.00 ERA.

At risk of contradicting myself and my prior position regarding won-loss record and the Cy Young, I've gotta give the nod to Skenes.  Had his record been below .500, it would've been a much more interesting case.  I think the fact that he managed to get to 10-10, though, speaks volumes.  Because he was well below .500 for a while.  As for the rest of my ballot, I've actually got the non-finalist Peralta at No. 2, with Yamamoto at No. 3.  Then the Phillies round it out, with Sanchez fourth and Luzardo fifth.

Much like Skenes, Tarik Skubal was the heavy preseason favorite in the American League.  And he could become the first back-to-back AL Cy Young winner since Pedro Martinez in 1999-2000.  Skubal was an ace in every sense of the word.  The best pitcher in baseball, he led the Majors in ERA (2.21), was second in the AL in strikeouts (241) and had a ridiculous 0.89 WHIP.  Most importantly, Skubal always came up big when the Tigers needed him to.

It might not be unanimous like it was last year, though.  Because Garret Crochet had quite a first season in Boston!  This is a guy who'd never started a game prior to the 2024 season.  Now he's one of the best starters in the game!  The Red Sox traded for him during the offseason, then paid him like an ace.  And he pitched like one.  Crochet went 18-5, trailing only Max Fried for the Major League lead.  He struck out 255 hitters, 14 more than Skubal.  And he threw 205 innings.  Exactly what an ace should do.

Throughout the season, most of the talk was about how the left-handed starters were dominating the AL.  Which was true.  Yet a righty managed to sneak in there as one of the finalists anyway--Houston's Hunter Brown.  In a rotation with much bigger names, Brown emerged as the Astros' most consistent starter, and Houston went 18-13 in his starts.  He was second (behind Skubal) in ERA and third (behind Crochet and Skubal) in strikeouts.

Just as I'm shocked Freddy Peralta isn't a National League finalist, I'm shocked Max Fried isn't one in the AL.  For most of the year, he was right up there in the conversation with Skubal and Fried.  Outside of one bad stretch when he was pitching hurt, he was brilliant.  And he stepped up to be the ace the Yankees needed with Gerrit Cole out for the year.  Fried led the Majors with 19 wins and was fourth in the AL with a 2.86 ERA.

There were two Phillies worthy of being in the NL discussion, and there are two Yankees worthy of being in the AL discussion.  Fried and Carlos Rodon were quite the 1-2 punch.  Rodon made 33 starts and went 18-9 with over 200 strikeouts and an opponents' batting average of .188.  Bryan Woo was excellent all year for that outstanding Seattle pitching staff.  And don't forget the closers!  Houston's Josh Hader, Seattle's Andres Munoz and, yes, Aroldis Chapman all put themselves in the Cy Young conversation.

Still, it's Skubal's award to lose.  He went into the season as the favorite to win, which is exactly what he'll do.  The vote could be close, though.  Because in any other year, Crochet might be your winner.  My third-place vote goes to Fried, with, I guess, Hunter Brown slotting in behind him and Carlos Rodon rounding out my top five picks.