Nobody wanted or asked for a 76-team NCAA Tournament. But the NCAA decided to expand it anyway. Nobody (except for the Big Ten commissioner) wanted or asked for a 24-team College Football Playoff. In fact, the opposition to the idea was quite clear and quite vocal. So, of course, the CFP didn't care about any of that and pushed forward with 24 teams anyway.
Big Ten Commissioner Tony Pettiti is thrilled of course. He's been pushing the 24-team playoff for a while (even if he was the only one who wanted it). Even the SEC, the other conference that stands to benefit the most, was against it. ESPN was, too, and they broadcast the freakin' games! But Pettiti eventually wore them both down and got his way. Which nobody else seems to be happy about. And they shouldn't be.
Getting into the College Football Playoff has always been hard. It's supposed to be. Under the four-team format, which many agreed was too exclusive, a second regular-season loss was enough to knock you out. There were even some one-loss and undefeated teams that didn't get in. Now, with 12 teams, a second loss doesn't hurt you too much as long as it was to a quality opponent. There's still some controversy regarding the selections, but not nearly as much as there used to be.
Next season's College Football Playoff will have a very "everyone gets a trophy" feel. All you need to do is be ranked in the Top 23 of the final CFP rankings in order to qualify (the final spot goes to the highest-ranked Group of Five champion, who would presumably be at least No. 24 anyway). There will likely be some three- and maybe even four-loss teams that make it. And, those three- and four-loss teams will almost certainly come from the Big Ten and SEC.
After Miami got the final spot in last year's CFP over Notre Dame, the "Notre Dame provision" became a hot topic. That provision guarantees Notre Dame a place if the Fighting Irish are among the top 12 in the final CFP rankings. It'll only apply this year. With the expansion to 24 teams, the "Notre Dame provision" will go away. Although, who are we kidding? Unless Notre Dame is God awful, there's no way they won't be in the Top 24 of the final rankings!
And, you'd be fooling yourself if you don't think the majority (if not all) of those 12 extra CFP berths will go to middle-of-the-pack Big Ten and SEC teams. Same thing with the extra eight bids in the NCAA Basketball Tournament. Those aren't going to mid-majors. They're going to the 11th-place team in Power 4 conferences. Tony Pettiti and Greg Sankey know this, too. Especially Pettiti. Why do you think he pushed so hard for it? (The current CFP Top 25 features nine SEC, six Big Ten and five Big 12 teams.)
The CFP committee is, of course, trying to sell people on why doubling the size of the playoff (only a few years after the field was tripled) is a good thing. It'll give the top four seeds a home game, which they don't have in the current format. And, instead of devaluing the regular season since teams have so much more margin for error, it'll increase competition since teams won't just be fighting to be in the top eight and get a first-round bye. They'll also be fighting for spots 9-16 to get a first-round home game, as well as those final eight spots.
In order to push the CFP expansion ahead, they had to make some major changes to the college football regular season schedule. Most significantly, they're eliminating the conference championship games. That was the big sticking point with the SEC, which generates a ton of revenue from its football championship game. Conference champions will be guaranteed a CFP berth, but it's up to the conferences to determine who that team is. How will tiebreakers work without a championship game? Especially if the teams in question didn't play each other or there are more than two teams tied? Would any of that even matter since they'll probably all be in the field anyway?
Those conference championship games have traditionally been held in the first weekend of December. The season will now end with the rivalry games on Thanksgiving Weekend, and the expanded College Football Playoff will start on the second Saturday in December. That was the Army-Navy date. So, as a result, Army-Navy is being moved up to what used to be that conference championship weekend. Although, that lets them keep their exclusive window as the final game of college football's regular season, so that's a reasonable compromise (and was a far better option than having it at the beginning of the season, which was also being discussed).
There's an obvious casualty to the expanded College Football Playoff, though. Bowl games. With 12 extra teams making the Playoff, that's 12 teams that won't be playing in bowl games. They already have trouble finding enough eligible teams to fill every bowl game. And that's with a 12-team playoff! Now, you're going to need teams for six bowls' worth of games! (And how many of those games have tie-ins to the Power 4 conferences and will lose those teams to the CFP?) That's a lot of sub-.500 Power 4 or mediocre Group of 6 teams.
What seems likely to happen is that some bowl games will fall by the wayside. Which isn't an entirely bad thing since there are far too many bowl games and most of them only exist to give ESPN programming over the holidays. And there are definitely some bowls that are just unnecessary. But, those games are important to the cities where they're played. So, while cancelling the Camelia Bowl might not seem like that big a deal, try telling that to the organizers of that game.
Just as significantly, it'll also water down the non-CFP New Year's Day bowl games. The Citrus Bowl and ReliaQuest Bowl are both Big Ten vs. SEC matchups. Even if that's the fourth- and fifth-place teams in each conference, that's still gonna be a pretty good matchup. This year, you'd be looking at maybe Ohio State and Iowa against Kentucky and South Carolina. Next year, they'd all be in the CFP, which would leave mediocre teams like Illinois and Penn State left to represent the Big Ten in those high-profile bowl games instead.
Adding 12 games to the College Football Playoff will obviously bring in a ton of money. Which is another reason why the Big Ten and SEC pushed so hard for it. But you're playing those games on campus. In December. Probably without students there. When the weather isn't the best. With those on-campus games in the first two rounds going head-to-head against the NFL on the Saturdays. And it's not like these are must-see matchups either. It's No. 17 at No. 16 or No. 23 at No. 10. (Just like how they're banking on people wanting to see two middle-of-the-pack Power 5 teams play each other for an 11-seed as their rationale for expanding the basketball tournament.)
Most importantly, and I can't stress this enough, they know people don't want it! They don't care. They made that known loud and clear. They know it'll make them a lot more money and that the SEC and Big Ten stand to benefit the most. Which are the only things that matter to them.
No comments:
Post a Comment